Reply sends your answer only to the person who sent the email. Reply all sends it to the sender and to everyone else in the To and CC fields. Neither one reaches people who were BCC'd, because their addresses are hidden from you. Use Reply by default, and Reply all only when everyone on the email needs your answer.
Most reply-all trouble comes from BCC, big distribution lists and a default button set to the wrong option. All three are fixable. Definitions of To, CC, BCC and other terms are in our email glossary.
Who gets your reply
Picture an email from Ana, sent to you and Ben, with Chris in CC and Dana in BCC.
- Reply goes to Ana only.
- Reply all goes to Ana, Ben and Chris. You can't see Dana's address, so your app can't include her.
Gmail and Microsoft describe it the same way: Reply all sends the message to the sender and anyone in the To and CC lines. One exception: if the sender set a Reply-To address, Reply goes to that address instead of the From address.
In Outlook, replies don't carry the original attachments, and Microsoft points you to Forward if you need to pass files on. Mail on iPhone has a Composing setting for including attachments with replies.
Not sure what To, CC and BCC mean? See what CC means in email and what BCC means in email.
What happens if you reply all to an email you were BCC'd on
You can do it, but it gives you away. Your reply goes to the sender and everyone in To and CC, so they all learn you received the original. Other BCC recipients still don't get it, because nobody can see their addresses.
Gmail tells you when you were BCC'd: the message shows you were added using BCC, and you can still see the To and CC recipients. Work accounts on Microsoft 365 go further. Outlook and Outlook on the web can show a warning (a "MailTip") when a BCC recipient clicks Reply All, explaining that everyone will see them.
If you were BCC'd and need to respond, click Reply so only the sender gets it.
When to use Reply and when to use Reply all
Use Reply when:
- your answer only matters to the sender ("Thanks, got it", "Yes, Tuesday works");
- you're responding to a big announcement or a distribution list;
- you were BCC'd;
- you want to say something privately, like a question you'd rather not ask in front of the group.
Use Reply all when:
- everyone on the email needs the information, for example a decision, a change of plan or an answer to a question the whole group was asked;
- leaving someone out would mean they act on old information.
Microsoft's own advice is a good habit: before you hit Reply All, ask whether everyone needs your reply. Often it's better to choose Reply and add only the people who do. If you do reply all, remove anyone who doesn't need it.
How to reply or reply all in Gmail, Outlook and Apple Mail
- Gmail on a computer: open the message and click Reply or Reply all below it.
- Outlook: open the message and select Reply or Reply All. The buttons sit at the top of the reading pane, beside the message or on the ribbon, depending on your version and screen size.
- Mail on Mac: hold the pointer over the message header and click Reply or Reply All.
- Mail on iPhone: tap the message, tap the reply button, then tap Reply or Reply All.
How to change the default reply button
If you keep hitting the wrong one, change which button is the default.
Gmail
- On a computer, click Settings > See all settings.
- On the General tab, find Default reply behavior.
- Choose Reply or Reply all, then click Save Changes.
Outlook.com and Outlook on the web
- Select Settings > Mail > Compose.
- Under Reply or Reply all, choose your default for replies from the reading pane.
In classic Outlook on the web, the same option is under Settings > Options > Mail > Automatic processing > Reply settings.
More Gmail settings like this one are in our Gmail guide.
How to avoid or undo a reply-all mistake
Turn on Undo Send. It holds your email for a few seconds so you can pull it back:
- Gmail: Settings > See all settings, then next to Undo Send choose 5, 10, 20 or 30 seconds.
- Outlook.com: Settings > Mail > Compose, where you can delay sending by up to 30 seconds.
- Mail on iPhone: you get 10 seconds by default. Go to Settings > Apps > Mail > Undo Send Delay to change it (up to 30 seconds).
Recall works only at work. Outlook's message recall needs both you and the recipient on Microsoft 365 work or school accounts in the same organization, and the message must still be unread. It isn't available for @outlook.com, @hotmail.com, @live.com or @msn.com addresses. Our guide on whether you can unsend an email covers every app.
Use BCC for big groups. If you email many people who don't need to talk to each other, put them in BCC. Their Reply all then only reaches you.
Can Outlook block Reply all? Not for a single email you send, as far as Microsoft's support pages show. What exists is at the organization level. Microsoft 365 has Reply-all Storm Protection, which detects a reply-all storm and blocks further reply-alls to that thread for a set number of hours. Admins see and tune it in the Exchange admin center. Exchange can also show a Large Audience MailTip when you address a big distribution group (by default, more than 25 members).
If you've already sent a reply all by mistake, a short follow-up to the same people ("Sorry, that was meant for Ana only") usually does less harm than a long explanation.
Reply all vs forward
Reply all answers everyone who already has the email. Forward sends the email to someone new, who wasn't on it, and it includes the original attachments. Forward when you want to bring a new person in; reply all when you're talking to the existing group.
FAQ
What is the difference between reply and reply all?
Reply sends your answer only to the sender. Reply all sends it to the sender and everyone in the To and CC fields of the original email.
Does reply all include BCC recipients?
No. BCC addresses are hidden from everyone else, so a Reply all can't include them. Only the sender and the To and CC recipients get it.
Can you reply all to a BCC email?
Yes, but your reply goes to the sender and everyone in To and CC, so they all find out you were BCC'd. Click Reply instead to answer only the sender.
How do I reply to just one person on a group email?
Click Reply to answer only the sender. To answer someone else on the email, start a new message to them, or click Reply and change the address.
How do I change the default from Reply all to Reply in Outlook?
In Outlook.com and Outlook on the web, go to Settings > Mail > Compose and choose Reply under Reply or Reply all.
Does reply all include attachments?
Usually not. Outlook doesn't include the original attachments in a reply, and Mail on iPhone has a setting for it under Composing. Use Forward if you need to pass the files on.
Sources
- Gmail Help: Reply to or forward emails
- Gmail Help: Send or unsend Gmail messages
- Microsoft Support: Reply to or forward an email message in classic Outlook
- Microsoft Support: Reply settings in Outlook on the web
- Microsoft Support: Recall or replace an email message that you sent
- Microsoft Learn: MailTips in Exchange Online
- Microsoft Learn: Reply-all storm protection report
- Apple Support: Reply to and forward emails in Mail on iPhone
- Apple Support: Unsend email with Undo Send in Mail on iPhone
- RFC 5322: Internet Message Format (sections 3.6.2 and 3.6.3)